Please note we are conducting maintenance on CCIWA from Thurs 2nd of November 8am until Mon 6th of November 8am.

During this time, you may experience disruptions to the website, including eCommerce & eLearning. We apologize in advance for any inconvenience this may cause. If you have any questions, please contact us on 1300 422 492 or email us at [email protected]

X

Free HR Services from our Employee Relations Experts. Find out more.

Our Business Services

Chamber of Commerce & Industry WA

With over 130 years of experience representing WA businesses, we’re ready to help with the resources and advice you need to succeed.

Employee Relations Helpline

Employee Relations Helpline

Get timely, reliable and practical employee relations advice on employment laws, the awards system and other human resource matters. CCIWA Members get unlimited access.

Legal Services

Legal Services

Our team of experienced, client-focused business lawyers offer a full range of Commercial Law & Employment Law services for all your essential legal needs.

Accounting & Taxation Services

Optima Partners and CCIWA

Innovative and personalised accounting, taxation and business advisory services that focus on delivering the best results to help your business grow.

Workplace Health & Safety Services

Workplace Health & Safety Services

Unlock the potential of your business with our suite of staff training and development programs, crafted by workplace relations experts and tailored to your business needs.

Construction & Mining IR Services

Construction & Mining IR Services

We offer extensive, independent and practical industrial and labour relations support to the engineering, construction and mining industries.

Workplace Training & Development

Workplace Training & Development

Unlock the potential of your business with our suite of staff training and development programs, crafted by workplace relations experts and tailored to your business needs.

Apprenticeship Support Australia WA

Apprenticeship Support Australia WA

Our dedicated team specialises in assisting employers maximise the benefits of investing in apprenticeships and traineeships to build local skills for the diverse WA workforce. Our team of experts will provide all the advice, support and services you need — free of charge.

Work Integrated Learning – Internships

Work Integrated Learning - Internships

Tap into WA’s future workforce with our Work Integrated Learning – Internships program. This free service facilitates university student work experience placements for your business.

Industry Capability Network WA

Industry Capability Network WA

Connecting your business with mining, construction, infrastructure, defence and other major projects using the ICN Gateway.

International Trade Services

International Trade Services

Take your business global using our comprehensive suite of international trade services to streamline importing and exporting, reduce risks and identify international partners.

Fall from grace in redundancy case

A church’s process for implementing redundancy has fallen afoul of workplace laws after the Fair Work Commission found the employer’s efforts merely gave “lip-service to the concept of consultation”.

The employee started work at the parish in 2012 in various secretarial functions.

The parish began reviewing its administrative functions in September 2016 and in January 2017 the employee proceeded on leave due to a worker’s compensation claim.

While the employee was away the parish’s reverend absorbed the employee’s duties. Following a review of work processes, he determined that the employee’s role was no longer required.

On the same day he completed a review document, he sent a letter to the archdiocese human resources department stating his intention to start the redundancy process.

The department informed the reverend that he needed to consult with the employee first and they would set up a meeting with her.

Commissioner Ryan said it was “irresistible” to draw the conclusion that because both documents were dated on the same day, they were prepared together for the purpose of bolstering the contents of the letter.

During the consultation meeting, the reverend was using a script prepared for him by the human resources department.

The Commissioner said the script merely gave “lip service to the concept of consultation” and that making the employee redundant was going to be implemented regardless of anything she may have said.

“The advice given … to (the reverend) led him into dealing with consultation as being nothing more than a mere formality to be gone through” he said. “It was perfunctory in the extreme.

“There was no sense of any genuine desire to seek the views of (the employee) before a firm decision was made. Rather, the decision was made and was to be implemented, unchanged.”

The Commissioner also said offers of redeployment were illusionary because the reverend merely pointed to job advertisements for other admin positions within the broader Catholic community, not within the organisation itself.

“The reality of this matter is that there were no possible redeployment opportunities and any suggestion to (the employee) otherwise was simply an exercise in misleading her and was also an exercise in trying to create an appearance of genuine consultation when there was no genuine consultation.”

Under the Clerks – Private Sector Award 2010, the reverend was required to properly consult with the employee.

The Commissioner said this had not been done and he deemed her dismissal unfair.

When considering the remedy, the Commissioner found the employee’s redundancy payout was fair and the work-related reasons behind her redundancy were sound.

He exercised his discretion to not grant a remedy.

This case serves as a reminder to employers executing redundancies that genuine consultation is critical in mitigating the risk of litigation. It is advisable to avoid the use of pre-prepared scripts and pre-drafted termination letters in such processes and to genuinely consider employee feedback.

Offers of alternative positions should only be made where they are available internally and for roles which the individual has the requisite skills, competence and training to successfully perform. For example, this may include positions that are at a lower level, lower pay rate, reduced hours or different location.

 

Share This Post